CVE & CISA-KEV Catalog

CVE-2025-21710

MEDIUM
5.5
CVSS v3
NVD

Description

In the Linux kernel, the following vulnerability has been resolved: tcp: correct handling of extreme memory squeeze Testing with iperf3 using the "pasta" protocol splicer has revealed a problem in the way tcp handles window advertising in extreme memory squeeze situations. Under memory pressure, a socket endpoint may temporarily advertise a zero-sized window, but this is not stored as part of the socket data. The reasoning behind this is that it is considered a temporary setting which shouldn't influence any further calculations. However, if we happen to stall at an unfortunate value of the current window size, the algorithm selecting a new value will consistently fail to advertise a non-zero window once we have freed up enough memory. This means that this side's notion of the current window size is different from the one last advertised to the peer, causing the latter to not send any data to resolve the sitution. The problem occurs on the iperf3 server side, and the socket in question is a completely regular socket with the default settings for the fedora40 kernel. We do not use SO_PEEK or SO_RCVBUF on the socket. The following excerpt of a logging session, with own comments added, shows more in detail what is happening: // tcp_v4_rcv(->) // tcp_rcv_established(->) [5201<->39222]: ==== Activating log @ net/ipv4/tcp_input.c/tcp_data_queue()/5257 ==== [5201<->39222]: tcp_data_queue(->) [5201<->39222]: DROPPING skb [265600160..265665640], reason: SKB_DROP_REASON_PROTO_MEM [rcv_nxt 265600160, rcv_wnd 262144, snt_ack 265469200, win_now 131184] [copied_seq 259909392->260034360 (124968), unread 5565800, qlen 85, ofoq 0] [OFO queue: gap: 65480, len: 0] [5201<->39222]: tcp_data_queue(<-) [5201<->39222]: __tcp_transmit_skb(->) [tp->rcv_wup: 265469200, tp->rcv_wnd: 262144, tp->rcv_nxt 265600160] [5201<->39222]: tcp_select_window(->) [5201<->39222]: (inet_csk(sk)->icsk_ack.pending & ICSK_ACK_NOMEM) ? --> TRUE [tp->rcv_wup: 265469200, tp->rcv_wnd: 262144, tp->rcv_nxt 265600160] returning 0 [5201<->39222]: tcp_select_window(<-) [5201<->39222]: ADVERTISING WIN 0, ACK_SEQ: 265600160 [5201<->39222]: [__tcp_transmit_skb(<-) [5201<->39222]: tcp_rcv_established(<-) [5201<->39222]: tcp_v4_rcv(<-) // Receive queue is at 85 buffers and we are out of memory. // We drop the incoming buffer, although it is in sequence, and decide // to send an advertisement with a window of zero. // We don't update tp->rcv_wnd and tp->rcv_wup accordingly, which means // we unconditionally shrink the window. [5201<->39222]: tcp_recvmsg_locked(->) [5201<->39222]: __tcp_cleanup_rbuf(->) tp->rcv_wup: 265469200, tp->rcv_wnd: 262144, tp->rcv_nxt 265600160 [5201<->39222]: [new_win = 0, win_now = 131184, 2 * win_now = 262368] [5201<->39222]: [new_win >= (2 * win_now) ? --> time_to_ack = 0] [5201<->39222]: NOT calling tcp_send_ack() [tp->rcv_wup: 265469200, tp->rcv_wnd: 262144, tp->rcv_nxt 265600160] [5201<->39222]: __tcp_cleanup_rbuf(<-) [rcv_nxt 265600160, rcv_wnd 262144, snt_ack 265469200, win_now 131184] [copied_seq 260040464->260040464 (0), unread 5559696, qlen 85, ofoq 0] returning 6104 bytes [5201<->39222]: tcp_recvmsg_locked(<-) // After each read, the algorithm for calculating the new receive // window in __tcp_cleanup_rbuf() finds it is too small to advertise // or to update tp->rcv_wnd. // Meanwhile, the peer thinks the window is zero, and will not send // any more data to trigger an update from the interrupt mode side. [5201<->39222]: tcp_recvmsg_locked(->) [5201<->39222]: __tcp_cleanup_rbuf(->) tp->rcv_wup: 265469200, tp->rcv_wnd: 262144, tp->rcv_nxt 265600160 [5201<->39222]: [new_win = 262144, win_now = 131184, 2 * win_n ---truncated---

How to fix

Remediation Available
linuxDebian
Fixed in:6.12.13-1CVE-2025-21710
Fixed in:6.12.13-1CVE-2025-21710
linuxUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-awsUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-aws-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-azureUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-azure-6.11Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-azure-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
linux-azure-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1022.23USN-7737-1
linux-gcpUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-gcp-6.11Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-gcp-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
linux-gkeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1028.32USN-7651-3
linux-gkeopUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1015.17USN-7651-3
linux-hwe-6.11Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-hwe-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-ibmUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-ibm-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29~22.04.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-6.11.0-1014-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1014.15~24.04.1USN-7521-3
linux-image-6.11.0-1014-lowlatency-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1014.15~24.04.1USN-7521-3
linux-image-6.11.0-1015-azureUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-1015-azure-fdeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-1015-gcpUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-1015-gcp-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-1022-oemUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1022.22USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-26-genericUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.11.0-26-generic-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1015-gkeopUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1015.17USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1022-azure-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1022.23USN-7737-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1028-gkeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1028.32USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1029-ibmUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-image-6.8.0-1029-oracleUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1029-oracle-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-nvidia-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-nvidia-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-nvidia-lowlatency-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-oemUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.31USN-7651-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1031-raspiUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.35USN-7651-6
linux-image-6.8.0-1032-awsUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1032-aws-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1033-gcpUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-6.8.0-1033-gcp-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-6.8.0-1034-azureUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-6.8.0-1034-azure-fdeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-6.8.0-2026-raspi-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-2026.27USN-7651-5
linux-image-6.8.0-64-genericUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-6.8.0-64-generic-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-6.8.0-64-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-6.8.0-64-lowlatency-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-6.8.1-1025-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.1-1025.26USN-7652-1
linux-image-awsUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-aws-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-aws-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-aws-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-aws-64k-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-aws-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1032.34USN-7651-1
linux-image-azureUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-azure-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-fdeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-azure-fde-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39~22.04.1USN-7737-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-fde-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1034.39USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1022.23USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-nvidia-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1022.23USN-7737-1
linux-image-azure-nvidia-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1022.23USN-7737-1
linux-image-gcpUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-gcp-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-gcp-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.11.0-1015.15~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-gcp-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35~22.04.1USN-7651-4
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-gcp-64k-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-gcp-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1033.35USN-7651-4
linux-image-genericUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-generic-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-generic-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-generic-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-generic-64k-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-generic-64k-hwe-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-generic-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-generic-hwe-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-image-generic-lpaeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-gkeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1028.32USN-7651-3
linux-image-gke-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1028.32USN-7651-3
linux-image-gkeopUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1015.17USN-7651-3
linux-image-gkeop-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1015.17USN-7651-3
linux-image-ibmUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-image-ibm-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-image-ibm-classicUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-image-ibm-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.29USN-7651-2
linux-image-kvmUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-64k-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-64k-hwe-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1014.15~24.04.1USN-7521-3
linux-image-lowlatency-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
linux-image-lowlatency-hwe-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1014.15~24.04.1USN-7521-3
linux-image-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-64k-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-lowlatency-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-lowlatency-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-nvidia-lowlatency-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-oem-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-oem-22.04aUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-oem-22.04bUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-oem-22.04cUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-oem-22.04dUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-oem-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.31USN-7651-1
linux-image-oem-24.04aUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.31USN-7651-1
linux-image-oem-24.04bUbuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1022.22USN-7521-1
linux-image-oem-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.31USN-7651-1
linux-image-oracleUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-oracle-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-oracle-64kUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-image-oracle-64k-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-oracle-64k-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-oracle-lts-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-image-raspiUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.35USN-7651-6
linux-image-raspi-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.35USN-7651-6
linux-image-raspi-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-2026.27USN-7651-5
linux-image-raspi-realtime-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-2026.27USN-7651-5
linux-image-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.1-1025.26USN-7652-1
linux-image-realtime-6.8.1Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.1-1025.26USN-7652-1
linux-image-virtualUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-virtual-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67USN-7651-1
linux-image-virtual-hwe-22.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67~22.04.1USN-7653-1
linux-image-virtual-hwe-24.04Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-26.26~24.04.1USN-7521-1
linux-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1USN-7651-2
linux-lowlatency-hwe-6.11Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1014.15~24.04.1USN-7521-3
linux-lowlatency-hwe-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-64.67.1~22.04.1USN-7651-2
linux-nvidiaUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34USN-7651-3
linux-nvidia-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-nvidia-lowlatencyUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.34.1USN-7651-3
linux-oem-6.11Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.11.0-1022.22USN-7521-1
linux-oem-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.31USN-7651-1
linux-oracleUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30USN-7651-3
linux-oracle-6.8Ubuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1029.30~22.04.1USN-7651-3
linux-raspiUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-1031.35USN-7651-6
linux-raspi-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.0-2026.27USN-7651-5
linux-realtimeUbuntu
Fixed in:6.8.1-1025.26USN-7652-1

Remediation is compiled from vendor and distribution security advisories. Always confirm against the linked source for your exact version and platform.

CVSS v3 Vector

Exploitability

Attack VectorLocal
Attack ComplexityLow
Privileges RequiredLow
User InteractionNone
ScopeUnchanged

Impact

ConfidentialityNone
IntegrityNone
AvailabilityHigh

CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:H

Exploit Intelligence

0.14%probability of exploitation in 30 days
4thpercentile

Low risk: more likely to be exploited than 4% of all known CVEs.

References

Related Vulnerabilities

Other CWE-667 vulnerabilities, ordered by exploit likelihood. View all

CVESeverityCVSSEPSSExploitedFix
CVE-2019-10072High7.573%-Fix
CVE-2002-1850High7.517%-Fix
CVE-2009-2699High7.514%-Fix
CVE-2004-0174High7.512%--
CVE-2009-4272High7.511%--
CVE-2020-24606High8.65.2%-Fix
Embed a live status badge for CVE-2025-21710
CVE-2025-21710 severity badge

Markdown

[![CVE-2025-21710](https://tridentstack.com/cve/badge/CVE-2025-21710.svg)](https://tridentstack.com/cve/CVE-2025-21710)

HTML

<a href="https://tridentstack.com/cve/CVE-2025-21710"><img src="https://tridentstack.com/cve/badge/CVE-2025-21710.svg" alt="CVE-2025-21710"></a>

Find and fix vulnerabilities across your fleet

TridentStack Control continuously scans your Windows, macOS, and Linux fleet for known vulnerabilities, prioritizes them by severity and active exploitation, and patches them automatically.

Start free

This product uses NVD data but is not endorsed or certified by the NVD. EPSS scores courtesy of FIRST.org (https://www.first.org/epss). Source: CISA KEV Catalog. Data as of 2025-12-16.